Why Did My Mortgage Payment Go Up in Year 2?
Updated 2026-11-21
Escrow shortage, the year-2 tax reset, the RESPA 2-month cushion, and how to check with your servicer.
Why did my mortgage payment go up in Year 2?
Most often the cause is property tax. Your lender collects tax in an escrow account. In year 1 it used the seller's old tax bill, which is often low. After you bought, the county reset the value of the home. The new tax bill was higher, and your servicer raised the monthly amount to match.
Two things can happen at once. Your monthly tax goes up for as long as you own the home. And your escrow account may be short, because it collected too little during year 1.
What is an escrow account?
An escrow account holds money for your property tax and homeowners insurance. Each month a part of your payment goes in. When a bill is due, your servicer pays it from the account. Your payment is then principal and interest, plus the monthly escrow amount.
Once a year the servicer runs an escrow analysis. It compares what came in with what went out, and sets the new monthly amount. That analysis is the moment your payment changes.
What is an escrow shortage?
A shortage means the account has less money than it should. It happens when a bill was higher than the servicer expected, which is common after a sale.
Shortage = months under-collected x (Year-2 monthly tax - Year-1 monthly tax) + RESPA cushion
What is the RESPA 2-month cushion?
RESPA is the federal rule for escrow accounts. It lets a lender keep a cushion of up to one-sixth of the year's expected escrow payments. That is two months.
RESPA cushion = Year-2 annual tax / 6
The cushion is part of your new monthly amount, and it can be part of the shortage too. This site applies the cushion to property tax only. Your own servicer may include insurance.
How is the shortage paid back?
A servicer may let you pay it as one lump sum, or spread it over 12 months. The 12-month version is temporary. Your payment rises for one year and then drops back to the new monthly tax level.
Monthly recovery = Shortage / 12
Year-2 payment = P&I + new monthly tax + insurance + PMI + monthly recovery (12 months only)
How much does each mill of tax add?
A mill is $1 of tax for every $1,000 of taxable value. On a $400,000 taxable value, each 1 mill adds $33.33 a month. Each 1% of rate adds $333.33 a month. This site does not guess your county rate, so enter your own from your tax bill.
Annual tax = taxable value x mill rate / 1000
Monthly tax = annual tax / 12
How do I check the numbers with my servicer?
Ask for your escrow analysis statement. Then check it against your own numbers:
- the old and new monthly tax amounts
- the tax value and rate the servicer used
- the number of months it counts as short
- the cushion it applied
- whether you can pay the shortage as a lump sum
How do I check with my county?
Your county assessor or appraisal office can tell you your current value, the exemptions on your home, and the total tax rate for your address. Some counties let you appeal a value you think is too high. Ask your county how and by when.
What if my home is new construction?
On new construction, the first tax bill can be based on the vacant land only. Once the finished house is on the tax roll, the next bill can be much higher, and your escrow can fall short. Ask the county for the full value of land plus house before you close.
Where can I calculate my own Year-2 payment?
Pick your state and enter your county rate and the seller's old taxable value:
Read property tax after you buy for how each of these states resets value.
Will my payment go back down?
The shortage part is temporary. If your servicer spreads it over 12 months, your payment falls once the 12 months end. The higher monthly tax stays, because it is the new normal for your home. Your payment can also change again if the tax rate, the value, or your insurance changes.
Can I pay the shortage in one amount?
Often yes. A lump sum lowers your monthly payment right away, because the servicer no longer spreads the shortage. Ask your servicer for the exact amount and the deadline. Compare it with your savings before you pay.
What else can raise my payment in year 2?
- Homeowners insurance. A new premium raises the escrow.
- A lost exemption. If a homestead exemption was not filed, your taxable value may be higher.
- A rate change. An adjustable-rate loan can reset.
- A buydown ending. Read the 2-1 buydown guide if you had one.
Ask your servicer to send the escrow analysis. It lists each item, so you can see which one moved.
Keep each escrow statement. Comparing two years side by side shows the change fastest.
If the new amount still looks wrong, ask your servicer for a written breakdown of the tax bill it used and the date it was paid. Compare it with the bill on your county website, because servicers sometimes pay a bill that was later corrected.
Try the calculator
Frequently asked questions
- Why did my mortgage payment go up in Year 2?
- Your lender collected escrow for year 1 using the seller's old, lower tax. After the county reset your home's value, the yearly escrow analysis raised your monthly tax, and it may have added a shortage.
- What is an escrow shortage?
- Shortage = months under-collected x (Year-2 monthly tax - Year-1 monthly tax) + RESPA cushion. It is the money your escrow account is missing.
- What is the RESPA 2-month cushion?
- RESPA lets a lender keep a cushion of up to one-sixth of the year's expected escrow payments, which is two months. Cushion = annual escrow payments / 6.
- How is the shortage paid back?
- You can usually pay it as a lump sum, or your servicer can spread it over 12 months. Monthly recovery = Shortage / 12. The 12-month increase is temporary.
- How much does one mill of tax add?
- On a $400,000 taxable value, each 1 mill adds $33.33 a month and each 1% of rate adds $333.33 a month. Enter your own county rate in the calculator.