Skip to content
Know your true home payment before you buy.

2-1 Buydown vs Price Cut vs Recast Calculator

Which is better for a seller credit: a 2-1 buydown, a price cut, or a recast? A $15,000 budget gives a year 1 payment of $1,717.83 with a buydown and $2,029.17 with a price cut. The buydown ends after 2 years.

$15,000

$5,000$30,000

One budget, spent three ways, so the comparison is fair.

Your numbers

Down payment $80,000. Loan amount $320,000. Full-rate payment $2,128.97 a month, principal and interest.

2-1 Buydown

Lowest first-year payment

Monthly P&I, Year 1
$1,717.83
Monthly P&I, Year 2
$1,918.56
Monthly P&I, Years 3+
$2,128.97
Total paid, 5 years
$120,280
Interest, 5 years
$101,501
Balance after 5 years
$301,221

Full 2-1 subsidy: $7,459 (Year 1 $4,934, Year 2 $2,525).

Budget left over after the subsidy: $7,541.

Price Cut

Monthly P&I, Year 1
$2,029.17
Monthly P&I, Year 2
$2,029.17
Monthly P&I, Years 3+
$2,029.17
Total paid, 5 years
$121,750
Interest, 5 years
$103,852
Balance after 5 years
$287,101

New price $385,000. New loan $305,000.

PMI already below 80% LTV (79.2% after the cut) — no PMI.

Recast

Monthly P&I, Year 1
$2,029.17
Monthly P&I, Year 2
$2,029.17
Monthly P&I, Years 3+
$2,029.17
Total paid, 5 years
$122,000
Interest, 5 years
$103,852
Balance after 5 years
$287,101

Balance after the lump sum: $305,000, re-amortized at the same rate and term.

Recast fee $250 is included in total paid. No credit check, no appraisal.

Monthly P&I, Years 1–5
Cumulative payment dollars saved vs doing nothing
Month 6Month 24
Unused escrow and new loan balance if you refinance
OptionUnused escrowBalance after refinance
2-1 Buydown$2,525$314,225
Price Cut$0$301,902
Recast$0$301,902

Unused buydown escrow goes to your loan principal. It is not lost.

What does the same dollar buy three ways?

Inputs: $400,000 home, 20% down, 7.00% fixed rate, 30-year term, $250 recast fee. Year-1 payment is the average monthly principal and interest.

Same budget spent three ways at three budget levels
BudgetOptionYear-1 monthly payment5-year total paid5-year interest
$10,0002-1 Buydown$1,717.83$120,280$101,501
$10,000Price Cut$2,062.44$123,746$105,554
$10,000Recast$2,062.44$123,996$105,554
$15,0002-1 Buydown$1,717.83$120,280$101,501
$15,000Price Cut$2,029.17$121,750$103,852
$15,000Recast$2,029.17$122,000$103,852
$20,0002-1 Buydown$1,717.83$120,280$101,501
$20,000Price Cut$1,995.91$119,754$102,149
$20,000Recast$1,995.91$120,004$102,149
$15,000Combo: buydown now, recast later$1,717.83Depends on the lump sum you pay after your old house sells

Combo, in plain words: take the buydown now for lower payments in years 1 and 2. When your old house sells, pay a lump sum on the loan and ask for a recast. Your payment drops again.

Should I take a 2-1 buydown, a price cut, or a recast?

It depends on how long you keep the loan. A seller credit, builder credit, or lender credit is one pool of dollars. You can spend it three ways. Each way helps a different kind of buyer.

  • 2-1 buydown: lowest payment now. It fades after year 2. Best if you expect to refinance or earn more soon.
  • Price cut: a smaller loan and a lower payment for every month of the loan. It can also remove PMI and lower your property tax.
  • Recast: you pay a lump sum on the loan after closing. The lender recalculates your payment on the smaller balance. Same rate, same term.

The calculator above spends one budget on all three, so you compare like with like.

How does a 2-1 buydown work?

A 2-1 buydown lowers your rate by 2 points in year 1 and by 1 point in year 2. From year 3 you pay the full rate. The seller, builder, or lender puts money in an escrow account at closing. Each month, the escrow pays the gap between the full payment and your lower payment.

With a $400,000 home, 20% down, a $320,000 loan, and a 7.00% rate, the full payment is $2,128.97 a month. In year 1 the rate is 5.00% and you pay $1,717.83. In year 2 the rate is 6.00% and you pay $1,918.56. From year 3 you pay $2,128.97.

The subsidy needed is $7,459: $4,934 in year 1 and $2,525 in year 2. A $15,000 budget covers all of it and leaves $7,541. If your budget is smaller than the subsidy, the buydown only covers what the budget buys. The calculator shows the month the money runs out.

What happens to unused 2-1 buydown money if I refinance?

It goes to your loan principal. It is not lost. If you refinance in month 12, the unused escrow is $2,525, and your balance falls to $314,225. Use the Refinance Exit slider to try months 6 to 24. A price cut and a recast have no escrow, so they show $0 unused. Confirm the rule in your loan documents, because it can vary by lender.

Is a price cut better than a buydown?

A price cut wins if you keep the loan for many years. At the default inputs, a $15,000 price cut makes the home $385,000 and the loan $305,000. Your payment is $2,029.17 from month 1, which is $99.80 less than the full payment, and it stays there for 30 years.

The buydown pays you more in years 1 and 2, but nothing after that. After 5 years, you have paid $120,280 with the buydown and $121,750 with the price cut. The balance is $301,221 with the buydown and $287,101 with the price cut.

How much does a recast lower my payment?

At the default inputs, a $15,000 lump sum leaves a $305,000 balance. Re-amortized over the same 30 years at 7.00%, the payment is $2,029.17. That is $99.80 less a month. The recast fee, $250 here, is added to your 5-year total of $122,000. A recast does not change your rate, and it needs no credit check or appraisal.

A recast is not the same as a price cut. It does not lower the price, so it does not lower your property tax or change your loan-to-value ratio at closing.

When does PMI drop off after a price cut?

PMI usually ends when your loan is 80% or less of the home value. At the default inputs, your starting loan-to-value ratio is 80.0%. After the price cut it is 79.2%. Enter your own down payment to see the month PMI drops off. Add your PMI rate from your lender quote to see the monthly saving.

Can I combine a buydown now with a recast later?

Yes. Take the buydown now to lower your first two years of payments. When your old house sells, pay a lump sum on the loan and ask for a recast. The recast lowers the payment for the rest of the loan. The size of the later lump sum is yours to choose, so the table shows this row without totals.

What are the formulas?

Monthly P&I = P x r / (1 - (1 + r)^-n)
  P = loan amount, r = annual rate / 12, n = number of months

2-1 buydown subsidy = Year 1 monthly savings + Year 2 monthly savings
  Year 1 savings = 12 x (payment at full rate - payment at full rate minus 2 points)
  Year 2 savings = 12 x (payment at full rate - payment at full rate minus 1 point)

Price cut loan = loan amount - budget

Recast payment = payment on (balance after lump sum) over (remaining months) at the same rate

LTV = loan amount / home value   (PMI usually ends at 80% or less)

When does each option win?

The buydown wins if you plan to refinance within a few years, or if your income should rise soon. The price cut wins if you plan to stay for many years, need PMI removed, or want a lower property tax bill. The recast wins if you already own the home, receive a lump sum later, or cannot get a price cut approved. Check every number with your lender before you choose.

Frequently asked questions

Should I take a 2-1 buydown, a price cut, or a recast?
Take the buydown for the lowest payment in years 1 and 2, or if you expect to refinance. Take the price cut or recast to lower every payment for the life of the loan. At $400,000 with 20% down, a 7.00% rate, and a $15,000 budget, year 1 costs $1,717.83 with the buydown and $2,029.17 with a price cut or recast.
How is the 2-1 buydown subsidy calculated?
Subsidy = Year 1 monthly savings + Year 2 monthly savings, where Year 1 savings = 12 x (payment at full rate - payment at full rate minus 2 points) and Year 2 savings = 12 x (payment at full rate - payment at full rate minus 1 point). At the default inputs it is $7,459.
What happens to unused 2-1 buydown money if I refinance?
It goes to your loan principal. It is not lost. At the default inputs, a refinance in month 12 leaves $2,525 unused, and the balance falls to $314,225.
Is a price cut better than a buydown?
A price cut is better if you keep the loan for many years. At the default inputs it lowers the payment by $99.80 a month for 30 years. The buydown lowers it more in years 1 and 2, then nothing.
How much does a recast lower my payment?
At the default inputs, a $15,000 lump sum lowers the payment by $99.80 a month, from $2,128.97 to $2,029.17. The recast fee is an extra $250, and you keep the same rate and term.
When does PMI drop off after a price cut?
PMI usually ends when LTV = loan amount / home value is 80% or less. At the default inputs, LTV after the cut is 79.2%. Enter your own down payment in the calculator to see the month PMI drops off.
What if my budget is smaller than the cost of a full 2-1 buydown?
The buydown only covers what the budget buys, starting with year 1. The calculator shows the month the money runs out. The full 2-1 costs $7,459 at the default inputs.
Can I use a buydown now and a recast later?
Yes. Take the buydown for lower payments in years 1 and 2. After your old house sells, pay a lump sum on the loan and ask for a recast to lower the payment for the rest of the loan.