Rent vs Buy Break-Even Calculator
Is it cheaper to rent or buy? Break-even is the month buying costs less than renting. On default inputs the mortgage payment alone is $2,128.97 against $2,000.00 rent. Empty costs count as $0, so the break-even is a floor. Enter your own costs.
Enter your monthly tax, insurance, and upkeep to see the break-even.
Rent
- Monthly cost, Year 1
- $2,000.00
- Total rent, 5 years
- $127,419
- Total rent, 10 years
- $275,133
Buy
- Monthly cost, Year 1
- $2,128.97
- Net cost, 5 years
- $45,250
- Net cost, 10 years
- $72,509
- Home equity, 10 years
- $262,967
Net cost = cash paid minus home equity if you sold that month.
How long until buying beats renting?
Default inputs: $400,000 home, 20% down, 7.00% fixed rate, 30-year term, $2,000 rent, 3% rent growth and 3% home price growth. Both growth rates are assumptions you can change. Property tax, insurance, upkeep, closing costs and selling costs start empty, so they count as $0 here and the net cost of buying is understated. No winner is shown for that reason. Enter real costs in the calculator to see the break-even.
| After | Total rent paid | Net cost of buying | Cash paid buying | Home equity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $24,000 | $10,297 | $105,548 | $95,251 |
| Year 3 | $74,182 | $29,078 | $156,643 | $127,565 |
| Year 5 | $127,419 | $45,250 | $207,738 | $162,489 |
| Year 10 | $275,133 | $72,509 | $335,476 | $262,967 |
Net cost of buying = cash paid (down payment, closing costs and every monthly payment) minus home equity if you sold that month.
Is it cheaper to rent or buy?
It depends on how long you stay and on the costs you enter. Renting has one cost: rent. Buying has many: the down payment, the mortgage payment, property tax, insurance, upkeep, and closing and selling costs. Buying also builds equity, which is the part of the home you own. The calculator above adds up both sides month by month and shows where the lines cross.
At the default inputs, the mortgage payment alone is $2,128.97 a month in Year 1. Rent is $2,000.00. That gap is small, so the costs you leave empty decide the answer. Empty fields count as $0, which makes buying look better than it will be. Enter your own numbers before you trust any break-even.
How long until buying beats renting?
The break-even is the month after which buying costs less than renting, and stays cheaper. It moves later when your property tax, insurance, upkeep, closing costs and selling costs are higher. It moves earlier when rent rises fast or the home gains value.
The calculator shows no break-even until you enter your monthly tax, insurance, or upkeep, because with those at $0 the answer would mislead. After 5 years the default inputs show $127,419 of rent against a net cost of buying of $45,250. After 10 years it is $275,133 against $72,509. Both leave tax, insurance and upkeep at $0. Once you enter real costs, a break-even computed with closing or selling costs left empty is still a floor.
What does "net cost of buying" mean?
Net cost is the cash you paid to own the home, minus the equity you would get back if you sold that month. At 5 years, the default inputs show $207,738 of cash paid and $162,489 of equity. At 10 years, they show $335,476 and $262,967.
Equity comes from two places: the loan balance falling, and the home price growing. The default price growth is 3% a year. It is an assumption, not a forecast. Set it to 0 to see buying with no price growth.
What does renting cost over time?
Rent starts at your monthly rent and grows once a year by the rent growth you enter. The default growth is 3% a year. That is also an assumption. Your lease and your city decide the real number.
What costs does the calculator leave out?
It does not model what you could earn by investing your down payment. It does not model tax savings from mortgage interest. It does not change your property tax when the county resets your value. It keeps property tax, insurance and upkeep flat. It uses one mortgage rate for the whole term. Use the property tax tool to see how your tax can change in Year 2.
What are the formulas?
Monthly P&I = P x r / (1 - (1 + r)^-n)
P = loan amount, r = annual rate / 12, n = number of months
Rent in month m = Year-1 rent x (1 + rent growth)^(whole years passed)
Total rent = sum of rent for every month so far
Home value in month m = price x (1 + home growth)^(m / 12)
Home equity = home value x (1 - selling cost %) - loan balance
Cash paid buying = down payment + closing costs + sum of (P&I + tax + insurance + maintenance)
Net cost of buying = cash paid buying - home equity
Break-even = first month after which net cost of buying stays at or below total rent
When does renting win and when does buying win?
Renting tends to win when you plan to stay a short time, when closing and selling costs are high, or when home prices are flat. Buying tends to win when you stay many years, when rent keeps rising, and when the home gains value. Your own numbers decide it. Enter your costs above and check them with your lender.
Frequently asked questions
- Is it cheaper to rent or buy?
- It depends on how long you stay and the costs you enter. At the default inputs, the mortgage payment alone is $2,128.97 a month and rent is $2,000.00. Property tax, insurance and upkeep start empty and count as $0, so enter yours before you trust any answer.
- How long until buying beats renting?
- Break-even = the first month after which the net cost of buying stays at or below total rent. The calculator shows no break-even until you enter your monthly tax, insurance, or upkeep. If closing or selling costs are left empty, the result is a floor, and real costs move it later.
- What does net cost of buying mean?
- Net cost of buying = cash paid (down payment, closing costs and every monthly payment) minus home equity if you sold that month. At 5 years the default inputs show $207,738 cash paid and $162,489 equity.
- Why are property tax, insurance and maintenance empty?
- This site does not guess your costs. Empty fields count as $0, which makes buying look better than it will be. Enter your own numbers. The property tax tool shows how your tax can change in year 2.
- What growth rates does the calculator assume?
- Rent grows 3% a year and the home price grows 3% a year. Both are editable assumptions, not forecasts. Set the home price growth to 0 to ignore price gains.
- Does it include investing my down payment?
- No. It does not model what your down payment could earn if invested, and it does not model tax savings from mortgage interest. It compares cash paid and equity only.
- How do closing and selling costs change the answer?
- They raise the net cost of buying, so the break-even moves later. Closing costs are added to cash paid. Selling costs are taken off your equity. Both start empty.
- What is the formula for the monthly mortgage payment?
- Monthly P&I = P x r / (1 - (1 + r)^-n), where P is the loan amount, r is the annual rate divided by 12, and n is the number of months.