Skip to content
Know your true home payment before you buy.

Buydown vs Price Cut

Updated 2026-11-21

Spend the same dollars on a buydown or a price cut, and see when each one wins.

What is the difference between a 2-1 buydown and a price cut?

Both use the same pool of money, such as a seller credit. A 2-1 buydown spends it on a lower rate for two years. A price cut spends it on a smaller home price, and so a smaller loan, for the whole loan. The buydown gives a bigger payment cut now. The price cut gives a smaller cut that never ends.

What happens to the payment when I spend the same dollars both ways?

Take the default example: a $400,000 home, 20% down, a $320,000 loan, a 7.00% rate, and a $15,000 budget. Without any help, the payment is $2,128.97.

Same budget spent three ways at the default inputs
OptionYear 1Year 2Year 3 and later5-year total paid5-year interestBalance after 5 years
2-1 Buydown$1,717.83$1,918.56$2,128.97$120,280$101,501$301,221
Price Cut$2,029.17$2,029.17$2,029.17$121,750$103,852$287,101
Recast$2,029.17$2,029.17$2,029.17$122,000$103,852$287,101

The buydown gives the lowest payment in year 1, at $1,717.83. The price cut gives $2,029.17 in every year, which is $99.80 less than the full payment. After 5 years, the buydown has cost $120,280 and the price cut $121,750. The loan balance is lower with the price cut, at $287,101, than with the buydown, at $301,221.

Does the size of the budget change the answer?

The budget changes the numbers, but not the pattern. This table spends $10,000, $15,000, and $20,000 three ways at the same default inputs.

Year-1 payment and 5-year total paid at three budgets
BudgetYear 1 buydownYear 1 price cutYear 1 recast5-year total, buydown5-year total, price cut5-year total, recast
$10,000$1,717.83$2,062.44$2,062.44$120,280$123,746$123,996
$15,000$1,717.83$2,029.17$2,029.17$120,280$121,750$122,000
$20,000$1,717.83$1,995.91$1,995.91$120,280$119,754$120,004

A larger budget lowers every option. A budget smaller than the full buydown cost only buys part of the subsidy, and the calculator shows the month it runs out. The full 2-1 buydown costs $7,459 at the default inputs.

When does a 2-1 buydown win?

A buydown wins when a low payment in the first two years matters more than the total cost. It fits a buyer who:

  • expects a raise or a second income soon
  • plans to refinance if rates fall, since unused escrow money goes to principal
  • needs cash for moving, repairs, or furniture in the first year

It does not win if rates stay high and you cannot refinance, because the payment steps up anyway.

When does a price cut win?

A price cut wins when you plan to stay for many years. It lowers the payment in every month of the loan. It can also help in two other ways:

  • PMI: a smaller loan lowers your loan-to-value ratio, so PMI may drop off sooner. Read when does PMI drop off.
  • Property tax: a lower price can lead to a lower assessed value, and so a lower tax bill. This depends on your county, so check with it.

A seller may agree to a credit but not to a lower price. Ask which one they will accept before you plan around it.

How does a recast compare?

A recast keeps the price and the rate. You pay a lump sum on the loan after closing, and the lender recalculates your payment on the smaller balance. At the default inputs, the payment is $2,029.17, the same as the price cut. The recast costs a fee, $250 here, so its 5-year total is $122,000 against $121,750 for the price cut. Read how to recast your mortgage for the details.

Can I do both a buydown and a recast?

Yes. Take the buydown for lower payments in years 1 and 2. When your old house sells, pay a lump sum on the loan and ask for a recast. Your payment drops again for the rest of the loan. The size of the later lump sum is yours to choose, so no single number covers every buyer.

How do I pick?

Ask how long you will keep the loan, and what you need most. If you need relief now, take the buydown. If you want the lowest cost over many years, take the price cut. Run your own numbers in the same-dollar simulator and confirm them with your lender.

What does each option do to my loan balance?

A price cut starts you with a smaller loan. A buydown does not touch the loan. It lowers what you pay for two years, and the escrow account covers the rest. A recast lowers the balance after a lump sum, then recalculates the payment.

The five-year table above shows this in dollars: what you paid, how much of it was interest, and what you still owe. A lower balance after five years means you own more of the home.

Which option fits which buyer?

  • You need the lowest payment now. The buydown gives the lowest payment in year 1 for the same dollars.
  • You plan to stay for many years. The price cut lowers every payment, and it lowers the loan for the full term.
  • You expect a lump sum later. A recast can use money you do not have at closing.
  • You expect to refinance soon. The buydown can make sense, and unused money goes to principal.

None of these is a forecast. They are the questions to ask before you pick.

What should I ask the seller or the builder?

Ask whether the credit can be used for each option. Some sellers can give a price cut, a credit toward closing costs, or a buydown, but not all three. Lenders also limit how much credit they will accept, and the limit depends on your loan type.

Ask for the choice in writing, and ask for the loan estimate for each one. Then enter your own price, down payment, rate, and budget in the calculator. The defaults on this site are examples, not offers.

Try the calculator

Frequently asked questions

Is a price cut better than a buydown?
A price cut is better if you keep the loan for many years. At the default inputs it gives $2,029.17 a month for the life of the loan. The buydown gives $1,717.83 in year 1, then $1,918.56, then $2,128.97.
Which costs less over 5 years?
At the default inputs, the buydown costs $120,280 over 5 years and the price cut costs $121,750. The price cut also leaves a lower balance, $287,101 against $301,221.
What if my budget is smaller than the full buydown cost?
The buydown only covers what the budget buys, starting with year 1. The full 2-1 buydown costs $7,459 at the default inputs.
Can a seller give a credit instead of lowering the price?
Often yes, but a seller may accept one and not the other. Ask which one the seller will agree to before you plan around it.
Can I use a buydown now and a recast later?
Yes. Take the buydown for lower payments in years 1 and 2. When you have a lump sum, pay it on the loan and ask for a recast.